Resources › The rules of the road (COLREGS)
Who Has Right of Way at Sea? The COLREGS Pecking Order
We commonly say that power gives way to sail. That's true, but it's only part of the picture. The COLREGS set out a hierarchy of vessel types, ranked by their ability to manoeuvre: the vessel least able to get out of the way sits at the top, and the others give way to her. It's not about status or importance. It's about capability.

Video, 9:05. Captions are available in the player.
In this lesson
From the top: not under command, restricted in ability to manoeuvre, constrained by draught, fishing, sail, power. This lesson explains how Rule 18 sets out that ladder, works down the top three categories, shows how to tell which side of a working dredge is safe to pass, and covers the Port Phillip rule that vessels under 50 metres keep clear of vessels over 50 metres.
- 0:00Why power giving way to sail is only part of it
- 1:01Why the hierarchy exists
- 2:11Read Rule 18
- 2:50The ladder of priority
- 4:16Vessel not under command
- 4:56Restricted in ability to manoeuvre: dredges
- 6:47On the water: a dredge in the Yarra
- 7:24Constrained by her draught
- 8:15Port Phillip: vessels over 50 metres
Read the transcript
We commonly say that power gives way to sail. That's true, but it's only part of the picture. The COLREGS set out a hierarchy of vessel types, ranked by their ability to manoeuvre. And the principle behind it is simple: the vessel least able to get out of the way sits at the top, and the others give way to her. Understanding the hierarchy matters because, in most situations, a vessel above you in the hierarchy is the stand-on vessel, even if she's approaching from your port side.
It also explains why vessels show the lights and shapes they do, which we'll come to in Module 7. Some of these vessel types you'll rarely meet. Others are surprisingly common on Australian waterways. Every rule in Section II we've looked at so far, crossing, head on and overtaking, assumes the vessels involved are free to manoeuvre. But some vessels aren't.
A vessel that's lost power can't hold a course. A dredge working in a narrow channel can't simply stop and move aside. A fishing vessel with her nets out can't make a sudden turn without losing her gear. The hierarchy exists to protect these vessels. By placing them higher in the order of priority, the rules make sure the vessels that can manoeuvre, and are therefore better placed to take avoiding action, are the ones that do.
It's not about status or importance. It's about capability. A motor yacht and a vessel not under command might be exactly the same size, but only one of them can respond to a developing collision situation, and the rules put the burden on the one that can. The hierarchy is built on a single principle. The vessel least able to manoeuvre gets the most protection.
The vessel most able to manoeuvre bears the greatest obligation to give way. Rule 18 is where this is all set out. But it's written as a series of sub paragraphs that can be hard to follow in sequence, so it's worth reading them all for yourself. Pause the video now, open your COLREGS, and read rule 18 in full. Notice how it opens: "Except where rules 9, 10 and 13 otherwise require." Keep that phrase in mind, because we'll come back to it.
Once you've read them, come back and hit play. Welcome back. And I hope rule 18 didn't send you to sleep. Well, Underneath all those sub-paragraphs, the structure is a simple ladder of priority. From the top: a vessel not under command.
A vessel restricted in her ability to manoeuvre. A vessel constrained by her draught. A vessel engaged in fishing. A sailing vessel. And at the bottom, a power driven vessel.
Each vessel gives way to those above it. I'll say that again, because it's worth committing to memory. Not under command. Restricted in ability to manoeuvre. Constrained by draught.
Fishing. Sail. Power. Strictly speaking, rule 18 doesn't rank a vessel not under command above a vessel restricted in her ability to manoeuvre. It lists them both as vessels the others must keep out of the way of, and says nothing about what happens when the two meet.
Most diagrams, including this one, in my book, still put NUC at the top. That reflects practice rather than the letter of the rule. A vessel not under command may have no control at all, while a vessel restricted in her ability to manoeuvre may be able to still steer, slow or stop, even only with difficulty. If the two ever meet, neither can claim priority though, under rule 18. So let's work our way down the ladder.
A vessel not under command sits at the top. Every vessel except one restricted in her ability to manoeuvre must keep out of her way, because she may have no steering or propulsion at all. You simply can't count on her getting out of your way. As we saw in Module 1 definitions, "not under command" doesn't mean there's no one on the bridge, or that the vessel's been abandoned. It means loss of engine power, loss of steering, a jammed rudder or a fouled propeller.
A vessel whose skipper has stepped below for five minutes is not a vessel not under command. Next comes a vessel restricted in her ability to manoeuvre, and for sailors in Australian waters, this is the category that matters most in practice. She sits above fishing vessels, sailing vessels and power driven vessels, and every vessel in those categories must give way to her. Rule 3 g lists the kinds of work that put a vessel in this category: laying or servicing navigation marks, cables or pipelines; dredging, surveying or underwater work; transferring people, stores or cargo while underway; launching or recovering aircraft; mine clearance; and towing that severely restricts her ability to turn. Of these, the one you're most likely to meet is the dredge.
A working dredge is almost always restricted in her ability to manoeuvre. She can't simply stop, she's connected to the seabed by suction pipes or a dredge head, and she follows a precise track dictated by the work she's doing. When a dredge is working, she'll show extra lights or shapes to tell you which side is obstructed and which side is safe to pass. On the obstructed side, where the dredge head, or pipes or spoil gear lie, she shows two all around red lights in a vertical line by night, or two black balls by day. On the safe side, she shows two all around green lights by night, or two black diamonds by day.
It follows the same logic as the rest of the COLREGS. Red means stop, green means go. And if you're approaching a dredge and can't clearly tell which side is which? Don't guess. Slow down, keep well clear, and call her on VHF channel 16 or the local port channel.
The value of a radio call was made very clear on a course a couple of years ago, as we motored down the Yarra River. A dredge was positioned diagonally across the channel, and it wasn't at all obvious which side was safe to pass. Rather than guess, I called him on the port VHF channel. The dredge master replied that he'd finished his run and would be getting underway at six knots within the minute. Which he did.
A potential close quarter situation resolved itself in thirty seconds. Not because the rules provided the answer, but because we used the radio. Third on the ladder is a vessel constrained by her draught. That's a power driven vessel whose deep draught, in relation to the available depth water, severely restricts her ability to deviate from her course. It's most relevant in narrow shipping channels, where large vessels have almost no room to move.
Rule 18(d) says other vessels "shall, if the circumstances of the case admit, avoid impeding the safe passage" of a vessel constrained by her draught. That's careful wording. It isn't quite a full keep out of the way obligation. It's an obligation not to get in the way of something that can't move. As a practical matter, if you see a large vessel in a narrow channel with very little room, give her a very wide berth, wherever she sits in the hierarchy.
And remember that local rules can go further than the COLREGS. In the port waters of port Phillip, the Harbour Master's Directions require vessels under 50 metres in length to keep clear of vessels over 50 metres. It's the same logic as the hierarchy: the vessel with more ability to manoeuvre keeps clear of the one that's constrained. So check the local rules wherever you sail. Well, that's the top of the ladder.
Now try Activity 5A and then come back for video 5B, where we'll look at fishing vessels, sailing vessels, seaplanes, and the exceptions that can override the hierarchy altogether.
More lessons on the COLREGS
These lessons come from The COLREGS Course, based on The Australian COLREGS Handbook, and support our practical sailing courses on Port Phillip.
