Resources › The rules of the road (COLREGS)

How Do You Know If You're on a Collision Course?

Constant bearing, closing range, equals risk of collision. Take a bearing. Wait a minute. Take it again. If it hasn't moved, act now. And if in doubt, assume the risk exists. The cost of being cautious when you didn't need to be is minimal. The cost of assuming you were safe when you weren't can be catastrophic.

How Do You Know If You're on a Collision Course?

Video, 7:29. Captions are available in the player.

In this lesson

In this lesson Tim explains COLREGS Rule 7, including the trap that a changing bearing doesn't always mean you're safe when approaching a very large vessel, a tow, or a vessel at close range. Then he walks through the four stages of a collision: awareness, risk confirmed, close quarters and immediate danger. The earlier you act, the more options you have.

Read the transcript

So you're keeping a proper lookout and you've spotted another vessel. Now what? Rule 7 tells you what comes next: work out whether there's a risk of a collision. And it tells you exactly how to do it. Rule 7(a) says: "Every vessel shall use all available means appropriate to the prevailing circumstances and conditions to determine if risk of collision exists. If there's any doubt such a risk shall be deemed to exist." That last sentence is one of the most important in the whole COLREGS.

If there's any doubt, treat it as if the risk exists. The cost of being cautious when you didn't need to be is minimal. The cost of assuming you were safe when you weren't can be catastrophic. Rule 7(b) goes on to require proper use of radar if it's fitted and working, including long range scanning and plotting. And Rule 7(c) says assumptions shall not be made on the basis of scanty information, especially scanty radar information.

A quick glance isn't enough to decide you're safe. Then Rule 7(d)(i) gives us the practical test: "Such risk shall be deemed to exist if the compass bearing of an approaching vessel does not appreciably change." It's a test you can use on any boat, in any conditions. Note the bearing to the other vessel, with a hand bearing compass, on the chart plotter or even by lining her up against a stanchion or a shroud, as long as you're holding a steady course yourself. And wait. Then take that bearing again.

In this example the bearing is zero five two degrees true at both observations, but the range has closed from an estimated two nautical miles to 1.1. Same bearing, closing range. That's a risk of collision, and action is required. I'll say that again, because it's one of the most useful things you'll take from this course. Constant bearing, closing range, equals risk of collision.

But here's a trap. A common mistake is to assume that any change of bearing means you're now safe. Well, the next Rule 7(d)(ii), warns that "such a risk may sometimes exist even when an appreciable bearing change is evident, particularly when approaching a very large vessel or a tow or when approaching a vessel at close range." With a very large vessel or a tow, she may be so long that even if her bow is drawing clear, her stern, or the tow behind her, may still be in your path. And when you're at a close range, a small bearing change at a tenth of a mile may not be enough to prevent a collision, because the geometry changes dramatically at close quarters. So: constant bearing, closing range, equals risk of collision.

Take a bearing. Wait a minute. Take it again. If it hasn't moved, act now. And if in doubt, assume the risk exists.

Rule 7(a) leaves no room for being optimistic. A collision doesn't happen suddenly. It develops through a sequence of stages, and each one is more constrained than the last. Understanding this progression is one of the most practically useful frameworks in seamanship, because it makes one thing very clear: the earlier you act, the more options you have. We'll keep coming back to these four stages throughout the course, so it's worth getting them clear now.

Stage 1 is Awareness. Two vessels are in proximity. You've detected the other vessel and you're monitoring the situation, but risk of collision hasn't yet been confirmed. This is the best time to gather information. Begin taking bearings, note the range, work out what type of vessel she is and where she sits in the hierarchy.

Rules 5 and 7, lookout and risk of collision, are your main obligations here. Crossing Bass Strait from Tasmania, we had light winds and visibility of less than two nautical miles. Given the amount of shipping in that area, and the fact that we were crossing a designated shipping lane, we were watching the AIS closely. We picked up a ship 12 nautical miles away, which, according to the AIS, would have come within 200 metres of us in 40 minutes' time. That was stage 1 of a collision.

"Proximity", in that context, with fast moving ships and poor visibility, easily means 12 nautical miles, even though the ship was still over the horizon. Stage 2 is risk confirmed. Constant bearing, closing range. Risk of collision has been established under Rule 7, and now the conduct rules of Part B govern who takes action and what action must be. Taken.

If you're the give-way vessel, this is when you must act: positively, early, and with an alteration big enough to be obvious. This is the stage where the vast majority of collision situations should be resolved. Stage 3 is close quarters. The situation has developed to the point where action by the give-way vessel alone may not be enough to avoid a collision. The stand-on vessel may now act, under Rule 17(a)(ii) once it's apparent the give-way vessel isn't acting.

And she must act, under Rule 17(b) once collision can't be avoided the give-way vessel must take action. Reaching stage 3 almost always means something has gone wrong earlier. Stage 4 is Immediate Danger. Collision is imminent. Rule 2 takes precedence over everything else, and both vessels must do whatever is necessary to avoid a collision, regardless of who technically has right of way.

There's no "I had right of way" at stage 4. There's only one question: what will stop this collision? So the key principle is this. The earlier you act, the more options you have. At stage one, you've all the time and sea room in the world.

By stage 4, both vessels are in extremis. Awareness, risk confirmed, close quarters, Immediate Danger. Aim to resolve every situation at stage 2, and you'll rarely see the other two. Now try Activity 2B, and then we'll finish the module with Rule 8, which tells you what your action should look like.

These lessons come from The COLREGS Course, based on The Australian COLREGS Handbook, and support our practical sailing courses on Port Phillip.